Harinder Sikka has sharply criticized filmmaker Meghna Gulzar for her adaptation of his acclaimed novel Calling Sehmat into the 2018 film Raazi, describing the decision as his “gravest misjudgment.” Sikka’s remarks come as he continues to voice dissatisfaction with the film, which starred Alia Bhatt and was both a critical and commercial success.
Sikka, who regards Calling Sehmat as one of the top books on espionage ever written, has expressed regret over his collaboration with Gulzar, stating, “Trust, but verify.” He alleged that her portrayal of the protagonist was diminished by ideological bias, which he claims twisted the narrative through a leftist lens.
Since 2020, Sikka has been vocal about his discontent with how Gulzar adapted his work. He noted that he was warned by others not to trust her, a sentiment that has lingered since the film’s release. “The way Meghna Gulzar twisted the story still pains me deeply,” he remarked, emphasizing his disappointment.
In addition to his grievances regarding Raazi, Sikka has also criticized Gulzar’s portrayal of the prominent military figure Sam Manekshaw in her upcoming film Sam Bahadur. His literary work continues to resonate with readers globally, and he is currently in the process of having more of his books adapted for the screen.
The film Raazi tells the gripping story of an Indian spy married into a Pakistani military family during the 1971 war, a narrative that has captivated audiences. Despite Sikka’s criticisms, the film’s success has solidified its place in contemporary Indian cinema.
As Sikka’s literary adaptations gain traction, observers are keen to see how these new projects will unfold, particularly in light of his recent comments about Gulzar. Details remain unconfirmed regarding the specifics of these adaptations and their potential reception.
